Choose whoever you think would be a good match, and would make you happy, and allow you to grow as a person. Which, from the sounds of it, is the other man. Just make sure the 'bad boy' aspect of him doesn't end up hurting you, or putting you in a bad situation.
Get Matched With a Therapist If you would like real online counseling from trained, Licensed, and Certified Professionals, visit our Therapists section to take a questionnaire and be matched with a counselor that's right for you.