If I had only been going out with the guy for a short time, I might be a little hesitant or slightly cautious about it all but if it had been for a longer period of time, I would totally accept it - if it had been a long time we had been dating when this came up, and I loved him, why would I not accept it? Especially if he was the person I wanted to spend my life with.
I too would (or rather do) have things about me that others might think are strange but if the person I loved did not accept it, that would disappoint me.
People of the world need to be more accepting and less judging toward others but that is an entirely different topic.