My sister thinks that I can’t trust her over a journal entry?

0

My older sister came to visit. Which is great, but at the moment we’re having our house renovated. My room and my siblings room got the floor replaced and the rooms painted. Right now we are in the midst of putting our belongings back in place. I was organizing some things inside some boxes and I came across some old journals that I wrote during my sophomore and junior year of high school. My sister was in the room with me and she took one of them and started reading the first page out loud. Panicking, I quickly snatched the journal saying,”don’t read that!” She got defensive replying with,”why?, you shouldn’t be embarrassed about whatever happened because it happened along time ago.”
I also found a fat book that I never finished and she started flipping through it while I was cleaning my room some more. I stopped to look at the old drawings I made, thinking that I was a terrible artist. She then came across another journal excerpt that I guess I wrote for some reason. When she started to read it I panicked once more and took it from her saying again,”don’t read that!”

She asks me very defensively,”why?”
Me:” I don’t want you to read it.”

My sis:”why?, will it make me not like you anymore?”

Me:”no, I just don’t want you to read it.”

My sis:”do you not trust me?”

Me:”no, I do trust you it’s just that I’m not comfortable reading it.”

My sis:”this happened along time ago, I don’t see why you have a problem with it.”

Me:”will you please respect that I’m not comefortable with it?”

My sister just gives me a look of why?

Me:”Why do you want to read it anyway?”

My sis:”because it’s your thoughts and I never get to hear or read your thoughts, it lets me get to know you more.”

I sigh,”Do you really want to read it that badly?”

“Yes.”, she replies

I hand her the fat book and let her read the journal excerpt.When she gets finished, she scoffs,”This was over something silly.”
I don’t say anything, she tells me,”You know I would let you read my journal.”
I don’t say anything for awhile, then we talk about other stuff.

Am I acting like a child for feeling this way?
Should I have let her read something from my journal?
I just feel ashamed that I didn’t let her because I feel like I can’t trust her or anyone to read my journals.

It’s just these are my thoughts and I shouldn’t feel obligated to share them if I don’t want to.

Any help?

Category: asked June 30, 2014

5 Answers

3
No, your sister has trouble respecting boundaries, and what no means. If she wanted to have a taste of your writing she could have asked you for a selection, chosen by you, of what you deemed a good representation of your writing. It was nice that you chose to be vulnerable and open, but if this is still bothering you, it might be because you felt pushed doing something uncomfortable. It's an useful experience to get to know how you react to insisting people, and how to behave next time.
0
There is no obligation for you to share anything. You have to decide if you are close enough with someone to share those types of things or not. Consider it may grow a relationship with another if you allow them to read your journals as it is kinda look into the way you think. It would probably take you a great deal of trust in the other person to open up and hope to not be harshly judged in return.
0
"It’s just these are my thoughts and I shouldn’t feel obligated to share them if I don’t want to." - enough said.
0
No, you are not acting childish by not allowing someone to read your journal. I've written loads of journal entries (5 and more journal notebooks over the years) but I still wouldn't let anyone to read them! Even though it's been three years, no way in the world would they read about what I wrote over some guy I used to be crazy with hahaha.Well, you don't need to let them read anything anyway. You have all your full claim of privacy in there. So don't get worried. It's just a normal response after being threatened to invade your privacy. Keep those journal entries where no one can find them.
0
well its been said before but the simple answer is no. There is nothing wrong with your desire to keep your journal private. It sounds like you wrote it with the intention that nobody else would read it. Some people are more comfortable then others with this type of thing but it amounts to having a reasonable expectation of privacy. In truth journals diaries and other forms of expression are delicate, its almost like holding part of somebody's soul (as in it is a pure manifestation of their thoughts and identity) so saying you don't trust her to read it is kinda like saying you don't feel comfortable bearing your soul because she asked. Sounds reasonable to me but hey what do i know